Three-time major winner Harrington, pictured here in a golf cap , said he believed the PGA of America had "chosen a friend" rather than necessarily the best candidate for the job.
Love, who is expected to be officially confirmed as captain for the 2016 contest was also at the helm when the US squandered a 10-4 lead at Medinah in 2012.
Harrington said he was surprised bookies favourite Paul Azinger didn't get the nod as captain. Azinger, who led the US to their last Ryder Cup victory in 2008 was tipped to return as captain this year, while three-time Presidents Cup-winning captain Fred Couples was also tipped.
But the US, looking to end a run of three straight Ryder Cup losses, will be led by Love.
Speaking to Sky Sports, Harrington said the PGA of America had "gone with the guy they like", adding "when you let the inmates run the asylum sometimes that's what they come up with."